June 2014
Bristol hairdresser jailed after baby died in his care
A FILTON man has been jailed after a four-month-old baby left in his care died. Bristol Crown Court heard that James Brown wrapped a blanket around Layla Rix-Palmer’s face while he was supposed to be looking after her. She stopped breathing and paramedics were unable to revive her.
He had previously dropped or allowed the baby to fall and pulled her out of her cot by one arm.
But the court heard that a post-mortem examination had not been able to ascertain a cause of death .
And when prosecutors approached expert Peter Fleming, Professor of infant health at Bristol University, he had told them that although the wrap around Layla’s face increased the risk of death, he could not be sure it was the substantial cause.
Advice was given to the police and Crown Prosecution Service that the case was not appropriate for a manslaughter charge and instead Brown, a 36-year-old hairdresser of Gloucester Road North, was charged with child cruelty.
He admitted the charge and Layla’s death was viewed as an “aggravating factor” when he was sentenced to four years in jail yesterday.
Brown held his head in his hands as he was sentenced.
Judge Graham Cottle told him: “You dropped or allowed her to fall.
“You pulled her out of her cot by one arm in a completely inappropriate way, risking serious injury.
“On one occasion she was covered in horrible blisters. The pain that must have caused that little baby can only be imagined.
“Then there was the final act. You wrapped her tightly in a blanket, and pulled the blanket tight over her head.”
Fiona Elder, prosecuting, said Layla was born on July 17, 2012 and died on November 14 of that year.
Miss Elder said: “At just short of four months old, she was a particularly vulnerable person.”
The court heard Brown minded Layla from the age of two months but in October, the baby had sustained an injury when she fell off a bed, bruising her head.
Miss Elder said: “It was relatively superficial and no medical attention was sought. By his plea he accepts that placing her on that bed and his inattentiveness to her was neglect.”
The baby’s mother, Brown’s then girlfriend, also saw him lift Layla by one arm and swing her into to his body, the court heard, and although she told him not to do it he continued to do so.
On one occasion he admitted dropping her and said she hit her head on a coffee table.
Miss Elder said: “The mum found an egg-sized lump on her daughter’s head. They went to the minor injuries unit and there was no significant damage.”
Brown also admitted popping blisters on the baby’s head, which he said were caused by her having a reaction to her pillow.
On November 14, 2012, the baby stopped breathing and her heart stopped.
Brown said the baby was wrapped in a blanket, around her face and was heard to say: “It’s all my fault she died.”
But Miss Elder stressed that experts were unable to rule out sudden infant death syndrome as a cause of death.
She told the court: “The most likely cause of death was the way she was wrapped, asphyxiation and the ingesting of vomit. Because infants die in their cots unexpectedly, they were not able to rule that out.”
Brown minimised his involvement when police interviewed him, saying he had worked in a children’s nursery and had two young children of his own.
He had no previous convictions, but a caution for common assault in a domestic setting.
Farah Rashid, defending, said Brown pleaded guilty to cruelty on the basis he allowed the baby to fall off a bed, lifted her by one arm on a number of occasions and popped blisters on her.
Miss Rashid said: “He accepts that him wrapping her up in the manner he did would have contributed to her fate on that day.
“He said ‘It’s all my fault she is dead’ to the police and paramedics and he continues to say that.”
“He says his actions were stupid. He says he really loved that girl and didn’t look after he properly.”
Afterwards, acting detective sergeant Lorna Withey said: “Sadly, due to available medical evidence, it was not possible to prosecute the defendant James Brown for more serious offences related to her death.
“My thoughts at this time are with Layla’s family.
“I am pleased with the sentence imposed by the court today, which reflects the defendant’s appalling treatment of this young baby.”
